Pine Crest School offers an extensive athletic program with fine facilities on both the Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale campuses. The pre-kindergarten through third grade classes focus on lead-up activities, eye-hand coordination, fitness, and gross motor movements. During school hours, Grades 4 and 5 mirror the seasonal team sports schedule by teaching the necessary skills and rules along with general fitness and swimming activities.

All Middle School students (Grades 6, 7and 8) can participate in an after-school sports program where Pine Crest teams play other private schools in the community (Gold Coast League). The team sports include basketball, softball, baseball, soccer, flag football, tennis, volleyball, and swimming.

Upper School students are encouraged to participate on one or more of over 60 teams and clubs, and the Panther spirit is kept alive by more than 800 competitors in interscholastic events. Students can join up to three teams during the school year.